It's not rape... it's shoplifting

This is a good place to drop general and weird news, entertainment, and general show prep material that might be interesting to air talent or producers. Hot dog threads ALWAYS welcome.

Moderators: The People's DJ, David Paleg

Post Reply
CoolBreeze
Member
Member
Posts: 1874
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2005 10:30 am

It's not rape... it's shoplifting

Post by CoolBreeze »

CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- Two prostitutes testified Monday in Kanawha Circuit Court that an East Bank man raped them at knifepoint in 2007. http://www.wvgazette.com/News/200908240793


We had this discussion on my talk show years ago. It turned out to be one of the most lively conversions of the year. It's my contention that you cant "rape" a prostitute, and should not be charged with that offense. At best, you should only be charged for shoplifting.

If a woman is self employed, running a business and selling something..... and you walk-in and steal that something, then in any other context you would be charged with shoplifting right? If you do this after hours, after she's closed the business, you'd be charged with "breaking and entering", or "entering without breaking".

If that same woman decides to sell her body as a business, and you steal her "goods" how can that be anything but shoplifting? After all, had you PAID for it she would have cheerfully given it to you right? But as you took it without paying, that's called a "business loss". Wal-Mart looses millions every year when people steal without paying, and so they simply mark-up the price for everyone else to offset the loss.

However, if you "shoplift" a prostitute while armed, that's completely different. Now you're into "armed robbery". Much more serious charge. Best to stick to convenience stores for this. :wink:
"I know I've got a lot against me: I'm White, I'm Protestant, I'm hard working. Don't you have an Amendment to protect me"? Archie Bunker
jag
Member
Member
Posts: 820
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 2:57 pm

Re: It's not rape... it's shoplifting

Post by jag »

Actually, the prostitute isn't selling his/her body as a product. Rather, in exchange for compensation, s/he is selling services which just happen to use the body as a means to an end.

"Rape" suggests force, or at least the taking against the will of (remember the poem "The Rape of the Lock?"). Thus, it's very possible to rape a prostitute. And, it's no less heinous a crime, regardless.
Post Reply