New car advice

This is a good place to drop general and weird news, entertainment, and general show prep material that might be interesting to air talent or producers. Hot dog threads ALWAYS welcome.

Moderators: The People's DJ, David Paleg

Post Reply
AmpedNow
Member
Member
Posts: 2415
Joined: Tue Apr 16, 2002 4:46 am
Location: none

New car advice

Post by AmpedNow »

I went to a local dealership to browse the 09 Corollas. Turns out I qualify for low APR deal that Toyota is running until the end of the month. 2.9% on 60 months.

I test drove the Sport model and really liked it. And I guess the sales guy thought I was sold right then and there, because most of the time, people are once they drive. However, I know there's a lot more cars where that one came from, and I'm in no hurry. My 03 still runs great, even though it just flipped 91k.

The deal he presented me looked ok, but something about it still bothers me. Here's the math...

Total MSRP: $20,400, give or take a few hundred. I know this is the high end price.

Trade in offer: $4,500. Edmonds says it's worth about $6,500, so I knew I was being lowballed on trade in value.

If I put down an additional $3k, That brings it down to roughly $16k on the loan.

$16,000 at 2.9% APR on 60 months equals monthly payments of $255 per month.

Much to the sales manager's amusement, I walked out on the deal. Heh.

This deal doesn't look too bad on paper. But somehow, I think I can do better... What am I missing?

The sales guy is really cool, and I can tell that he's just a good guy trying to make a living. I want to give him a sale but at a fair price.

How would you handle this?

:mrgreen:
User avatar
genlock
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 5867
Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2001 4:09 pm
Location: OW

Re: New car advice

Post by genlock »

Nothing wrong with your present car? Only 91k?
Keepit, save 255/month and your addtl down payment 3k.
Estimate how much longer you can drive the old one (months times 255) plus 3k.
When it comes time to buy a car you will have a big down payment.
After all it took you 4 and a half years to put 91 k on the old one then you could have close to 14 k plus the 3k down payment in the bank.
Plus bank interest. Thats a good down payment in 4.5 years. You may even have another 3 k to add to it and a trade in worth 2k or so.
Lets say 22k. Then you can bargain from strength with those assholes for the lowest price, as you will have most if not all of the purchase cash.
Your best bet is to keep driving the old car (assuming no big safety or maintenance issues) for as long as it will go while saving the monthly car payment. I am assuming there are no family or personal ego problems driving the sale. YMMV
"Everyone Should be aware that you're just a screen grab away from infamy."
AmpedNow
Member
Member
Posts: 2415
Joined: Tue Apr 16, 2002 4:46 am
Location: none

Re: New car advice

Post by AmpedNow »

No,there is nothing wrong with my old one. It's just nice to drive a new car. So maybe it is an ego thing...

:lol:

I'm probably not going to bite now. Your advice is genius...

But assuming I did, could I have done better?

I think the lowball trade in offer is what really hung me up... After all, one of Toyota's main selling points is their high resale value, and I just didn't see it in this deal.

I'd like to hear how others with more life experience has handled buying new cars. And if they would have bit on this deal.
User avatar
Arp2
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2139
Joined: Fri Mar 25, 2005 10:58 pm

Re: New car advice

Post by Arp2 »

K-Rock wrote:I went to a local dealership to browse the 09 Corollas. Turns out I qualify for low APR deal that Toyota is running until the end of the month. 2.9% on 60 months.
In the past (stronger years than this), Toyota's done, once or twice a year, 0% on shorter terms and $500-$1000 rebates. I think I'd wait and see if that -- or better -- happens again. Plus, Toyota Financial Services pays the dealer when the dealer sells a loan for it; assuming you've already done your research and negotiated the price, ask what that kickback amount is and then ask to reduce the price of the car by two-thirds of that amount...assuming you think they're telling you the truth. (The amount back to the dealer should be somewhere in the $500-$1000 range, so that could/should get you another $500 or so. I could be wrong about that, though...for some reason, I'm now thinking $400-500, meaning about $300 for you....)
I test drove the Sport model and really liked it.....Total MSRP: $20,400, give or take a few hundred. I know this is the high end price.
Yes, it is. The "Sport" is the mid-level model, so that price seems $4000 high! Then again, I think the closer I can get to a decade between car purchases the better, so it's been a good amount of time since I've paid attention to the price of any car.
Trade in offer: $4,500. Edmonds says it's worth about $6,500, so I knew I was being lowballed on trade in value.
Retail or trade? Either way, sell it yourself....unless your schedule is crazy busy and creating money for you, it's an inconvenience that'll put you two-to-three grand ahead.
How would you handle this?
Put off buying for several years....most of the most well-off people I know drive "old" cars!
"I don't know the same things you don't know."

"Yes, you do; you just won't admit it!"


"Yeeee...it looks like a 'Belt Buckle & Ball Cap' convention in here......"
Bob Loblaw
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 566
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2001 5:37 pm
Location: Over here

Re: New car advice

Post by Bob Loblaw »

K-Rock wrote:I'd like to hear how others with more life experience has handled buying new cars. And if they would have bit on this deal.
Don't buy brand new. Buy Used, but only a year or two old or so. Fools trade those in a lot! People like shiny things.

Get your financing from your bank. They'll almost always have better rates and are more apt to loan to you since you're already a customer. Easier to make payments too.

(two points from a financial credit wiz who comes in once a month to record podcasts)
User avatar
Hoosier Daddy
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2927
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2002 11:35 am
Location: Not 100% in love with your tone right now.

Re: New car advice

Post by Hoosier Daddy »

I'll reiterate the whole new car vs. used car thing. Buy a *gently used* car from a reputable dealer. "Program cars" or "dealer cars" are great deals, and, with the factory warranty reaching the 5 to 7 year anniversary on some vehicles, you're a fool to buy new unless you have money to burn. The last two cars I bought had less than 5,000 miles on them when purchased and both were priced several thousand dollars less than the new model sitting right beside it. Got the dealer prep. Got the remainder of the factory warranty. Hell, the car even smelled new. From my experiences, gently used is the right way to go.

I'll also ditto the bank thing. We have a good relationship with a local bank that financed the last couple of vehicles, as well as some farm property I once owned, and our new house. They KNOW we make our payments on time, and, since they own us anyway, we can usually get a better deal on interest rates as opposed to having the dealership do it all with their banking contacts.

Just my $0.02.

8)
Translators are a Pox on the FM radio dial.
jag
Member
Member
Posts: 820
Joined: Thu Aug 29, 2002 2:57 pm

Re: New car advice

Post by jag »

Truth be known, Toyota has slipped in terms of quality from "beyond belief" to simply "extraordinary." The new Corolla is a very nice car, but it has been de-contented somewhat (manual windows in the lower lines, for example). Give it a year or so to shake out the few bugs it could have.

In the mean time, check out the Nissan Versa. Roomier, cheaper, good performance. And, the Civic is always a good bet. But, if you want a new car and you want to spend as few dead Presidents as possible, consider the Hyundai line. The warranty is unbeatable and the prices have yet to catch up with the domestics and other Asian cars, so you could upgrade for less than you expect. You might even be able to move up to the next class of vehicle. Not only that but the quality is surprisingly good.

What are you driving now?
Bob Campbell
Member
Member
Posts: 2232
Joined: Mon Dec 19, 2005 12:13 pm
Location: Blue Heaven

Re: New car advice

Post by Bob Campbell »

Gotta agree with the "Program" car advice. Get one around September for a great deal. But with only 91k on what you have, keep that one dude. At least til this time next year. With the state of the economy, the cost of oil and gas, and the implosion of the credit markets, now is probably not a great time to make ANY major purchase. By this time next year, things may not be better (probably I mean), but should be a bit clearer. We may be at the juncture of some major paradigm shifts in our economy and it's safer to have the extra cash in the bank right now.
Your dick might want the new car, but your brain will need the cash.
User avatar
Hoosier Daddy
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2927
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2002 11:35 am
Location: Not 100% in love with your tone right now.

Re: New car advice

Post by Hoosier Daddy »

Bob Campbell wrote:... But with only 91k on what you have, keep that one dude. At least til this time next year. With the state of the economy, the cost of oil and gas, and the implosion of the credit markets, now is probably not a great time to make ANY major purchase. By this time next year, things may not be better (probably I mean), but should be a bit clearer. We may be at the juncture of some major paradigm shifts in our economy and it's safer to have the extra cash in the bank right now.
Your dick might want the new car, but your brain will need the cash.
Excellent advice. 100,000 miles on a personal vehicle is nothing these days, provided you've changed the oil, bought new tires when necessary, scheduled the occasional tune up, and generally taken care of your ride. If maintenance isn't nickel-and-diming you to death on your present automobile, don't go in debt right now and trade for a new one.

8)
Translators are a Pox on the FM radio dial.
User avatar
Dr. Whiplash
Member
Member
Posts: 694
Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2005 10:35 am

Re: New car advice

Post by Dr. Whiplash »

Now that's a whole boatload of solid advice. Only thing I can add: I wouldn't trade in to a dealer in most circumstances, particularly with an older car. Sell to an individual and use the cash on your down payment.

The difference would be greater if you were shopping for, say, a new Impala. They might offer you "$5000 trade-in" but if you walk in without a car you're going to get $1500 off MSRP, thus the trade-in offer was only $3500. Seems obvious but otherwise intelligent people fall for it every day.
Last edited by Dr. Whiplash on Sat Apr 26, 2008 12:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Hoosier Daddy
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2927
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2002 11:35 am
Location: Not 100% in love with your tone right now.

Re: New car advice

Post by Hoosier Daddy »

K-Rock wrote:I test drove the Sport model and really liked it. And I guess the sales guy thought I was sold right then and there, because most of the time, people are once they drive.
Just for the record, what you described is part of "How To Sell A Car 101", a required class for anyone in the new or used car business. They want you to drive the new vehicle, smell that new car smell, notice how it goes faster and doesn't have that almost inaudible rattle or noise that just drives you crazy about your present car...

It's all part of the sales pitch. And when you trade, that one guy will come out to look your old car over, audibly exhale a few times as he makes notes on his clipboard, shake his head a few times, or whatever. It's nothing but a show. They're getting you mentally prepared to be low-balled on the trade-in offer, hoping to keep their resale profit margin as high as possible. Act III occurs later when your salesman (always the good guy, always likeable, and always on your side in this scripted performance) takes the agreed-upon figures to his boss, ready to "go to the mat for you" and get you this incredible deal of a lifetime. Heck, he'll probably be fired for trying to sell a car for such a low price, but you're worth it, so he's going to do it anyway!

Uh, yeah.

The trick is to see the game for what it is before you enter the door. KNOW what your old car is worth. KNOW what you can afford (they always price your new vehicle within $100 higher a month of what you're paying now or were paying - forcing you to upsize your loan from your last car payment agreement). HAVE your own financing in place to use unless they offer an really incredible deal from some other lender. And ALWAYS be prepared to walk away, even if it's just for a day or so to think things over. NEVER be in a hurry to buy a car.

8)
Translators are a Pox on the FM radio dial.
User avatar
Arp2
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2139
Joined: Fri Mar 25, 2005 10:58 pm

Re: New car advice

Post by Arp2 »

Arp2 wrote:
K-Rock wrote:I test drove the Sport model and really liked it.....Total MSRP: $20,400, give or take a few hundred. I know this is the high end price.
Yes, it is. The "Sport" is the mid-level model, so that price seems $4000 high! Then again, I think the closer I can get to a decade between car purchases the better, so it's been a good amount of time since I've paid attention to the price of any car.
...and, as a result, I have to stand corrected.

I happened by a Toyota dealer last night after hours and took a moment to take a look. It appears the Corolla is now available in four trim levels, up from three, with the "Sport" now being above the "LE" and under a new (and rare?) "XLE." And "destination" appears to be higher. Well......alrighty, then.

Still seems high. :)

By the way, I used to be completely in the "finance it yourself" camp. Now, though, I think you have to at least take a look at what the manufacturer's finance arm has to offer. As long as it's something with the normal, regular, compounding interest (as opposed to whatever it's called when the total interest is calculated as "the cost of financing" and added to the principal as a fee with that total being divided by the number of months to determine the payment; the result of that is zero incentive or what amounts to a penalty for paying it off early), I can't see any reason not to at least consider it.
"I don't know the same things you don't know."

"Yes, you do; you just won't admit it!"


"Yeeee...it looks like a 'Belt Buckle & Ball Cap' convention in here......"
User avatar
Hoosier Daddy
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2927
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2002 11:35 am
Location: Not 100% in love with your tone right now.

Re: New car advice

Post by Hoosier Daddy »

Arp2 wrote:By the way, I used to be completely in the "finance it yourself" camp. Now, though, I think you have to at least take a look at what the manufacturer's finance arm has to offer. As long as it's something with the normal, regular, compounding interest (as opposed to whatever it's called when the total interest is calculated as "the cost of financing" and added to the principal as a fee with that total being divided by the number of months to determine the payment; the result of that is zero incentive or what amounts to a penalty for paying it off early), I can't see any reason not to at least consider it.
Agreed.

8)
Translators are a Pox on the FM radio dial.
User avatar
The People's DJ
Pimp Hand
Pimp Hand
Posts: 779
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2004 3:26 pm
Location: Not in Wheeling...thank God.

Re: New car advice

Post by The People's DJ »

Hoosier Daddy wrote:
Arp2 wrote:By the way, I used to be completely in the "finance it yourself" camp. Now, though, I think you have to at least take a look at what the manufacturer's finance arm has to offer. As long as it's something with the normal, regular, compounding interest (as opposed to whatever it's called when the total interest is calculated as "the cost of financing" and added to the principal as a fee with that total being divided by the number of months to determine the payment; the result of that is zero incentive or what amounts to a penalty for paying it off early), I can't see any reason not to at least consider it.
Agreed.

8)

DAMN! It's cold in here.

Did hell freeze over?

:mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen:
User avatar
Arp2
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2139
Joined: Fri Mar 25, 2005 10:58 pm

Re: New car advice

Post by Arp2 »

Hoosier Daddy wrote:
K-Rock wrote:I test drove the Sport model and really liked it. And I guess the sales guy thought I was sold right then and there, because most of the time, people are once they drive.
Just for the record, what you described is part of "How To Sell A Car 101", a required class for anyone in the new or used car business. They want you to drive the new vehicle....
Yeah....I can't remember the exact figure, but it's something like the odds of a customer buying the car at some point go up to three out of four once he or she has driven it. Getting the customer in the car and driving it is, yes, statistically speaking, the single best thing a salesperson can do.
It's all part of the sales pitch....It's nothing but a show....your salesman (always the good guy, always likeable, and always on your side in this scripted performance) takes the agreed-upon figures to his boss, ready to "go to the mat for you" and get you this incredible deal of a lifetime. Heck, he'll probably be fired for trying to sell a car for such a low price, but you're worth it, so he's going to do it anyway!
While there's a certain amount of sameness to the whole process no matter where you go, K-Rock is probably seeing something a little different at a Toyota dealer, though.

I know (or used to know; it's been a couple of years) a Toyota sales manager, and we've talked the business a little bit. He said he almost prefers car business rookies when he hires salespeople because they don't have the usual habits; but, if he hires people with experience, there are two variations on the "80/20" rule that are the reverse of the usual that he has to absolutely drill into their heads -- the usual games, gimmicks, and tactics are never going to work on 80% of the Toyota customers, and 80% of Toyota customers are going to come in knowing as much or more about the vehicle than the salesperson typically would (just like a pop-quiz in school, he regularly tests his salespeople on all the vehicles at their meetings).

As soon as the salesperson identifies the customer as being a "typical" Toyota customer, he or she is trained to cut about 98% of the BS, establish the relationship and get the database information (the bulk preferably from the driver's license as the customer is sent out in the car), ask if there's "anything the customer's research didn't answer" about the vehicle (definitely use the word "research"), move the conversation to the dealer level by sharing the dealer's commitment to 100% customer satisfaction and unbelievably convenient service, make a half-joking attempt to sign the customer at sticker, and then go ahead and get really real about the price.

"From the start, Lexus-buyers have always been like graduate-level Toyota-buyers of the time, but what's changed for us is that Toyota-buyers are now like junior Lexus-buyers," he told me. "They don't have the same money, but they're about as sharp."
The trick is to see the game for what it is before you enter the door. KNOW what your old car is worth. KNOW what you can afford (they always price your new vehicle within $100 higher a month of what you're paying now or were paying - forcing you to upsize your loan from your last car payment agreement). HAVE your own financing in place to use unless they offer an really incredible deal from some other lender.

Yes....to that, I would add, though, "always be negotiating the price, never the payment." If and when the salesperson starts talking about payment, say something like, "the payment, if there's going to be one, isn't really relevant at this point; right now, we're talking about the marketplace value of the car, aren't we?" If asked what your current payment is, give a dirty look and say, "if I even have one, it has absolutely no relevance to the value of this car." If he says the relevance is that it might affect the payment on this car, refer back to the other.

And ALWAYS be prepared to walk away, even if it's just for a day or so to think things over. NEVER be in a hurry to buy a car.
Yes....a couple of ways to play this.

Method 1: Make your first visit on a Tuesday or Wednesday early in a month. Float back in every 5-10 days and take things a step further without ever letting the salesperson close. As the end of the month approaches, try to be encouraging the dealer to have what you want on the lot but don't commit to buying yet. With just a day or two left in the month (especially if the month ends early or mid-week), go for it. At that point, the salesperson's motivation (desperation) is at its highest, and the manager is probably bugging him about this guy on his list who's darn near hanging out around the place but never getting sold!

Method 2: If the dealer is relatively unimportant to you, use the internet to locate a dealer with the exact car you want in stock. Show up out of the blue around 1 or 2 on the Saturday afternoon at the end of the month, acting like you just dropped in on a whim or saw something that caught your eye while driving by. "Take a liking" to the car you want but claim it's missing something you "almost need" or, even better, has something (an "extravagance") you don't care about or don't want and is, as a result, priced too high. Use that and the "on a whim" arguments as levers as you pretty much let yourself be sold. Try to take your browsing, test drive, and negotiation up close to the store's closing time...you'll have "cost" the salesperson, his manager, and his finance guy the whole last Saturday afternoon of the month, and they'll definitely want to get you done. This method is a little bit tough if you're bringing your own financing, though...your story suddently gets awful fishy. If you're going to whip that check or letter on them, make sure you have every last thing already negotiated, on the contract, and signed by them.

Tip: Surrender no information until you're serious! If dealing with multiple dealers, decide who's going to get which phone number (cell, home, spouse's cell, etc...only one number to each dealer) and give first name only! Don't give up your license until absolutely necessary and, when you do, insist on making the copy yourself, completely "redacting" everything but name and (maybe) address with a black marker you "happen to" carry in your pocket. Using anything you give them, they're going to run your credit and probably get the upper hand.
"I don't know the same things you don't know."

"Yes, you do; you just won't admit it!"


"Yeeee...it looks like a 'Belt Buckle & Ball Cap' convention in here......"
AmpedNow
Member
Member
Posts: 2415
Joined: Tue Apr 16, 2002 4:46 am
Location: none

Re: New car advice

Post by AmpedNow »

jag wrote:Truth be known, Toyota has slipped in terms of quality from "beyond belief" to simply "extraordinary." The new Corolla is a very nice car, but it has been de-contented somewhat (manual windows in the lower lines, for example). Give it a year or so to shake out the few bugs it could have.
I felt the same about the 2003 Corolla, which is what I have. That was also a big redesign year. But surprisingly, there have been no recalls on it to date. It's been a great car.

As for Toyota reliability issues, I will agree that they are not infallible, but I think we're still good there overall... They are very anal retentive about quality control. They're not getting worse. It just that everyone else is catching up to them.
In the mean time, check out the Nissan Versa. Roomier, cheaper, good performance. And, the Civic is always a good bet. But, if you want a new car and you want to spend as few dead Presidents as possible, consider the Hyundai line. The warranty is unbeatable and the prices have yet to catch up with the domestics and other Asian cars, so you could upgrade for less than you expect. You might even be able to move up to the next class of vehicle. Not only that but the quality is surprisingly good.
Yes, yes, and yes. I'm impressed with Honda Civic, and the redesigned Nissans.

Even on the domestic side, the Chevy Cobalts and the redesigned Malibu Sports are really nice. I used to be staunch GM before I became an Asian convert...

:mrgreen:

This is some great advice, guys. Thanks.
User avatar
cgarison
Member
Member
Posts: 2032
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2001 11:28 pm
Location: The Encampment

Re: New car advice

Post by cgarison »

K-Rock wrote: $16,000 at 2.9% APR on 60 months equals monthly payments of $255 per month.
That looks about right.

But why are you trading? My 2003 is running great with 99750 miles on the clock and I am looking to put a set of 65000 mile radials to get another 2 years out of my car.

Beware first year cars. Despite the fact that the sheetmetal did not change on my car, it got all new suspension and mechanicals. I have had a few "first year" headaches on my car which you would not expect for a body style that has been around for 10 years when I purchased it.
The first step in a successful revolution is to defeat all competing revolutionaries.
User avatar
Scott Reppert
Member
Member
Posts: 1446
Joined: Tue Dec 18, 2001 12:50 pm
Location: Fairmont, WV

Re: New car advice

Post by Scott Reppert »

Best advice on here:

1. Get the most out of the car you have so that you can save up your money for a bigger future down payment on whatever car you choose.

2. Avoid first year cars.

Worst advice on here (sorry, Hoosier):

1. Buying a "gently used" used car. Why buy a used car? You already have one...

Scott (who purchased the 2007 Corolla S the last time we had a thread like this on here!)
Scott Reppert
Music Director/Program Director/On-Air Personality
WTCS/WFGM/WMQC/WAIJ/WLIC/WRIJ/WKJL/WRWJ/WPCL/WWPN
Operations Manager: Hope Radio, T8WH, Palau
Production/Editor: "Believe Right" and "MFC WorldWide"
"For mine eyes have seen Thy salvation"--Luke 2:30
User avatar
Hoosier Daddy
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2927
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2002 11:35 am
Location: Not 100% in love with your tone right now.

Re: New car advice

Post by Hoosier Daddy »

Scott Reppert wrote:Worst advice on here (sorry, Hoosier):

1. Buying a "gently used" used car. Why buy a used car? You already have one...
Noooooooo! :D

You're getting an almost new car at a used car price, including the balance of the factory warranty.

Hopefully, you're replacing a vehicle at least 7-10 years old.

:wink:
Translators are a Pox on the FM radio dial.
User avatar
cgarison
Member
Member
Posts: 2032
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2001 11:28 pm
Location: The Encampment

Re: New car advice

Post by cgarison »

I have never purchased a showroom new car. My current car was a current year model vehicle and was priced $15K less than the one on the showroom floor. Can't beat that kind of a discount especially if you keep your car more than 4 year. As for me, I am hoping for another 75K on my car before I trade. I see similar models all over every major city with 250K on the clock and not getting the care that mine has received.

Sad part is I need tires, shocks/struts, and an alignment. That is going to run me $1,000. But consider the tax on a new car. Much cheaper when that is considered. :mrgreen:
The first step in a successful revolution is to defeat all competing revolutionaries.
Post Reply